What To Do With Leftover Halloween Candy

Originally published November 1, 2018. Updated October 28, 2019

The season is upon us once again. If you’re like me, you buy way more candy than you’ll ever pass out, and now you’ve got half a bag of leftover Halloween candy, and you know it will only hinder your efforts to get or stay healthy. What to do? Never fear! I’ve got some ideas for you!

what to do with leftover halloween candy

The mindset for wellness

First, let’s talk about mindset. I know how it feels to give away, or otherwise dispose of, food that is yours. Especially if it’s food you really like. Trust me, being a dietitian does not absolve me of loving sweets (Reese’s are my favorite!)! But here’s the thing – most of us eat WAY too much of it WAY too frequently. It gets away from us. We forget how much we’ve eaten. We justify it. We chalk it up to weak resolve, or whatever. And before we know it, the bag is empty and there’s a mountain of wrappers sitting on the table.

“I might as well just eat the rest of it, and then it will be gone!”

“I can’t get rid of those Snickers bars! They’re my favorite!”

Sound familiar?

If you find you’re thinking similar thoughts, try answering the following questions:

– What is your health or wellness goal?
– How will keeping all that candy around contribute to or inhibit that goal?
– Is the candy more or less important that reaching that goal?
– What does that candy represent to you that you hesitate to let it go? This is getting deep but sometimes we need to go there!

For most of us, of course the candy isn’t more important that our health or wellness goals, but it’s still difficult to come to terms with the idea. In times like these, ask yourself: “What would my ideal self do?” That’s the person you want to be – the person you are after you reach all your goals and you’re living the life you want to live, the way you want to live it. 

If your ideal self wouldn’t eat all the candy, read on!

Donate your leftover Halloween candy

There are lots of charities around that will accept unopened leftover Halloween candy! No more feeling bad about just throwing it in the trash! Contact your local homeless shelters and food banks to see if they accept it. Several organizations also put together care packages for soldiers overseas using donated candy. Here are some options to find a donation center near you:

Operation Gratitude
Halloween Candy Buy Back

Take it to work

This is a great way to spread the love! Put a bowl in the break room at work and the candy will be gone in no time! This also works for extra baked goods you may have at ANY time of the year!

Freeze it and ration it

There’s truly nothing wrong with having a piece of candy here and there. Freezing it allows you to ration it better because you don’t have a huge pile of candy sitting in front of you, and you won’t mindlessly eat it because it has to thaw – unless you’re the type to eat it frozen! Take one or two pieces out to thaw at a time for snacking.

If you already know you’re not the type of person to be able to have just one or two, this option may not be for you. Be honest with yourself.

Give leftover candy away

Give it to a family member, friend, or neighbor who would appreciate it.

Leftover Halloween candy.

Many people struggle this time of the year – the time I’ve dubbed “Hallo-thanksgiv-mas.” This year, you can make it different. Be the person you want to be right now. You can do it!

How do you get rid of leftover Halloween candy that supports your health and wellness? Let me know your Hallo-thanksgiv-mas wins in the comments section!

2 thoughts on “What To Do With Leftover Halloween Candy

  • November 1, 2018 at 8:10 pm

    The freezer idea is great!!! It helps you to forget about the candy.

    • November 1, 2018 at 8:14 pm

      Out of sight, out of mind!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *